In-House Counsel’s Holiday Wish List: Insights from In-House Employment Counsel on Delivering Stellar Client Service
by: Sharina Rodriguez, Esq. Associate Attorney at Nukk-Freeman & Cerra, PC Employment Attorneys and Adriana Foreman, Esq., Labor & Employment Attorney | Labor Relations | Business Restructuring
In-house employment counsel operate under constant pressure—balancing business realities, risk management, and fast-evolving workplace laws. For outside counsel, providing excellent legal work is just the starting point. True partnership requires insight, efficiency, and an understanding of the client’s unique operational landscape. To explore what separates “good” from “exceptional” client service, we spoke with several experienced in-house employment attorneys (just in time for the holidays) who shared candid advice on how outside defense counsel can better support their teams, anticipate needs, and strengthen collaboration – a wish list of sorts. While preferences will ultimately vary by client, the perspectives we gathered reveal a consensus on not only what in-house counsel value most, but also how outside counsel can build enduring, trusted relationships in an increasingly competitive market.
If in-house counsel had a holiday wish list, this would be it:
Q: What are key qualities you value when selecting outside counsel?
A: Some of the key qualities in-house counsel reported valuing most were subject matter expertise, professional reputation, cost, geographic location, and diversity. They are looking for intentional and strategic thinkers who are responsive, proactive, and offer creative solutions when necessary. In terms of responsiveness, in-house counsel stressed the importance of acknowledging receipt of emails, providing an estimated timeframe on when a more fulsome response will be provided and communicating any changes as necessary. Similarly, in-house counsel look for partners who are self-starters—those who proactively provide updates and make recommendations without being prompted. Ultimately, they are looking for counsel they can trust and rely upon.
Q: What steps can outside counsel take to ensure they understand and align with business goals?
A: It is essential that you understand the essence of your client’s business. Start by conducting external due diligence – research the company, review earning statements (if dealing with a public company), check recent litigation dockets involving the company, and understand any regulations that may impact the client’s business (e.g., FTC, government regulations). As outside counsel, it is important to understand the legislative landscape that affects the business and the parameters within which the business must operate. Next, speak to your in-house counsel. Be curious and ask questions about how the company operates, what their business and legal teams’ goals are, and what their risk appetite and litigation approach look like.
Q: Are there any tasks in which you prefer outside counsel to exercise discretion without your input?
A: Generally, it was reported that while outside counsel has some discretion to handle the day-to-day tasks related to a case or matter, in-house counsel wants the opportunity to sign off on substantive items, risk management assessments, and big picture strategy. Others mentioned that if the task involves setting deadlines or making representations on behalf of the client, such as filing documents, presenting a settlement posture, or communicating with a judge or other party, then in-house counsel should be aware in advance and looped in for approval. Ultimately, the level of discretion outside counsel can exercise is built over time as they learn about and develop their relationship with the client. During strategic discussions, outside counsel should always be prepared to provide a sound and well-thought-out recommendation.
Q: What frequency of updates do you expect from outside counsel on active matters?
A: During the preliminary stages of a case or legal issue, in-house counsel prefer frequent updates regarding case strategy, key milestones, and important deadlines. That may mean weekly or biweekly updates, particularly as the case and budget assessments are being prepared. Once the case strategy is determined, outside counsel should update in-house counsel whenever there are any developments in the case – such as pleadings or discovery responses being filed or served, or significant communications with opposing counsel. At the very least, updates should be provided on a monthly basis. Of course, the frequency of updates will depend on the client or the stage of the engagement. Indeed, some in-house counsel reported wanting weekly updates given their large caseload, while others mentioned wanting more frequent updates as the case approaches settlement, hearings, or trial. Outside counsel should speak with their clients to understand their preferences and exercise discretion regarding the scope and frequency of updates. The general consensus is that in-house counsel do not want any surprises! This applies to both the case status and budget.
Q: What standards do you expect from outside counsel in terms of timeliness of work product?
A: Five to seven business days seems to be the sweet spot for most in-house counsel regarding when they expect to receive work product. However, this depends on the nature of the work product at issue. For complex projects, such as motions for summary judgment, in-house counsel may require more time to review and assess defense strategy, and outside counsel should ascertain the client’s preference. It is extremely important to in-house counsel that outside counsel deliver work by agreed-upon deadlines and they urge outside counsel not to commit to deadlines that they cannot meet. Keeping open lines of communication is key, and generally, in-house counsel prefer to discuss a realistic timeframe that works for both parties over a promise that cannot be kept.
Q: How do you prefer outside counsel provide their legal analyses and recommendations, and what standards do you expect in terms of the quality of their work product?
A: Do not be afraid to pick up the phone! Outside counsel should always be mindful about providing delicate information in writing and should offer phone calls for such conversations. Otherwise, if you have been asked to prepare a recommendation in writing, generally, the preferred method for communication is email with concise bulleted points. When a legal memorandum is prepared, it is important to include an executive summary at the outset briefly explaining the issues, the reason for the memo, and the risks and recommendations. It is important to present in-house counsel with all potential options for their consideration. Even if you may not think one of the options is the preferred solution, ensure that you outline the risks for each option, so the business has all the information they need to determine the best course of action. Further, it was suggested that when providing a deliverable, you consider including a short overview or draft email that the in-house attorney can easily flip to their internal business clients. This “deliverable plus” approach provides an opportunity for you to make the in-house attorney’s job easier, which frankly is the ultimate goal!
In terms of what quality standards are expected, in-house counsel expects work product that is thoughtful, clear, and concise, and without typos or erroneous citations. Attention to detail is key.
Q: What are some appreciated best practices for billing or expense reporting?
A: More detail! In-house counsel want to see detailed time entries in order to better understand where time is being spent. If time is being billed over several days for the same or similar tasks, ensure that each billing entry differentiates the specific work performed and explains the need for additional time. For example, if you are working on a motion for several days, each time entry should detail the specific sections of the brief being drafted, the legal issues researched, or the strategies being explored. In-house counsel also stressed the importance of submitting all bills promptly and identifying timekeepers at the outset of the case, so they can easily identify them during their review of the bills.
Outside counsel should understand the client’s budget and the value estimate of the case, and act accordingly. Moreover, it is important to keep in-house counsel apprised of the status of the budget and when there is a risk of exceeding the budget. In some cases, in-house counsel will need prior approval to exceed a budget and must provide the business with justifiable reasons for the budget increase.
Also, while billing preferences are client-specific, keep in mind that outside counsel can sometimes negotiate different payment schedules for bills, expenses, or costs. Some businesses may be amenable to issuing payment for expenses and costs sooner. Do not hesitate to explore different options with clients to find arrangements that work best for both parties.
Q: Under what circumstances have you ended a relationship with outside counsel?
A: Relationships with outside counsel have ended under many circumstances including when outside counsel failed to understand the business goals of the organization and was not mindful of significant increases in defense costs. In other instances, in-house counsel ended relationships when they felt a lack of support and trust due to poor work product, failure to communicate case updates, and a lack of proactive recommendations on next steps and strategy. Additionally, failing to respect the in-house counsel’s opinion and direction and going above their head to the General Counsel (or other superior) when there is a difference in opinion has proven to be a sure way of losing the client’s trust and business.
Q: What email subject lines help you identify the case and matter best?
A: In general, the plaintiff/case name, a brief description of the subject matter, and any deadlines should always be included in the subject line. Depending on the client, you may also want to include the corporate entity involved. In some cases, we were informed that “For [Attorney Initials]” should be included at the outset to flag that the particular email requires the in-house counsel’s attention. If the email contains a time sensitive issue, place “URGENT”, “TIME SENSITIVE”, or “RESPONSE NEEDED” at the beginning of the email to flag its importance.
Q: What description do you prefer in calendar invites?
A: Generally, the case name and a brief description of the topic will be sufficient. Some in-house counsel reported wanting a “Privileged & Confidential” marking added at the end of the invite. However, the description on a calendar invite will depend on the client as sometimes other employees within the business have access to counsel’s calendar, which may raise some confidentiality concerns and require a more cryptic description.
Important Takeaway
The theme emerging from these conversations is clear: the best outside counsel are not just excellent lawyers—they are strategic partners who understand their clients’ business realities, communicate with precision, and deliver practical, timely solutions. In-house employment counsel value collaboration, responsiveness, and a deep appreciation for the balance between legal risk and operational need. By investing in relationships, anticipating challenges, and viewing each engagement through the client’s lens, outside counsel can transform their role from service provider to indispensable advisor. In an environment where legal expertise is expected, it is the quality of partnership that truly sets stellar counsel apart.
About the Author
Sharina Rodriguez, Esq. and Adriana Foreman, Esq.,
Associate Attorney
Nukk-Freeman & Cerra, PC Employment Attorneys
Sharina Rodriguez, Esq., has focused her practice in employment litigation and counseling involving age, race, sex and disability discrimination and/or harassment, retaliation, whistleblower, wage and hour, restrictive covenants, and breach of contract disputes arising under
Sharina graduated from Rutgers Law School where she
participated in a variety of activities and programs including: Moot Court, Minority Student
Program, Legal Research, and Writing Teaching Associate Program, and Association of Latin
American Law Students. She also participated in the Rutgers Entrepreneurship Clinic, where she
acted as a student attorney representing emerging businesses. federal, New Jersey and New York law. Her experience also includes counseling private and public employers in all areas of employment law, including with respect to COVID-19 related issues. She has developed an expertise in drafting and revising employee handbooks and policies and conducting investigations of workplace complaints.
Adriana devotes a substantial portion of her practice to business restructuring and M&A matters. She advises employers on employment issues related to reductions in force and other business restructuring and downsizing matters, including
compliance with federal and state Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Acts and the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act (OWPBA). In addition, she performs preacquisition due diligence for corporate clients and private equity firms to identify employment obligations and liabilities that may impact the value and structure of a corporate transaction. Adriana also conducts internal investigations and maintains an active litigation practice where she represents employers before federal and state courts, administrative agencies such as the National Labor Relations Board, and in arbitration.
Adriana also conducts internal investigations and maintains an active litigation practice where she represents employers before federal and state courts, administrative agencies such as the National Labor Relations Board, and in arbitration. Prior to joining Littler, Adriana worked at a global law firm as part of the firm’s financial restructuring and insolvency group. She
also served as a law clerk to the Hon. Robert E. Grossman of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of New York
Hey NELC Members!
Are you interested in writing substantive law articles like this and getting published in the NELC Quarterly Newsletter? Click here to submit your content/topic ideas.
© 2025 National Employment Law Council (NELC)