As employers navigate the challenges and complexities of maintaining a fair and respectful workplace, the importance of prompt, thorough and effective investigations has never been more crucial. In over 15 years of handling workplace investigations and litigating their aftermath, I have seen many mishandled investigations that cost the company time and money, and fracture employee trust. Whether conducting, overseeing, or litigating workplace investigations, here are five critical mistakes to avoid:
Choosing the Wrong Investigator: Sensitive investigations are often best handled by a specific person selected on a case-by-case basis. Make sure to select an investigator who has the experience, background, and soft skills to set you up for success. Sexual harassment investigations, for example, might benefit from an empathetic attorney more likely to elicit accurate responses from the complainant and witnesses with trauma-informed questioning. Similarities in language, dialect, ethnicity, military experience or other characteristics can often make the difference in accurate reporting because these similarities may increase the amount of trust the accused, accuser, and/or witness has in the investigator, making them more forthcoming. Depending on the complexity of the investigation, it is also helpful to select an investigator who has experience with the specific type of complaint made. Another consideration for complex investigations that have a high likelihood to result in litigation, is to assign them to someone equipped to handle the rigors of litigation and cross-examination.
Finally, selecting your “go to investigator” might be a mistake if they don’t have time to deliver a prompt and thorough investigation.
Failing to Control the Scope of the Investigation: Experienced investigators will prepare for the investigation by reviewing documents, identifying witnesses, narrowing the issues, and even sketching out the questions that need to be explored and answered by key witnesses. However, investigators need to be flexible to include additional witnesses, documents, and maybe even issues that arise during the course of the investigation (e.g., putting someone on administrative leave, suspending an employee, or changing someone’s shift temporarily).
The challenge is in balancing such flexibility with focus on the key issues to avoid “scope creep.” Scope creep is when an investigation’s focus and purpose become unclear or muddled, often due to new information discovered during the process, which can result in the investigation deviating from its original objectives. Bottom line: unfocused investigations can be perceived as minimizing the most problematic areas of concern, or even retaliatory if the complainant or witnesses feel they have been targeted as a result of their complaints. Thus, investigators must prioritize complaints and focus on the most egregious issues instead of running down every concern a witness brings to their attention. Experienced investigators will intake peripheral complaints that arise during the course of the investigation and highlight them to the client to determine whether to either include them in the original investigation or have them investigated separately.
Scope creep can not only inhibit the investigator’s ability to reach conclusive results, but it can also cost the business as more people, documents, and witnesses are pulled into the investigation. As witnesses identify additional witnesses, be sure to ask what information these people have, so you can avoid unnecessary interviews that waste resources and disrupt the business as employees speculate about the expanding scope of your investigation.
Reaching Legal Conclusions in a Workplace Investigation: A workplace investigation calls for factual conclusions, not legal findings. Even if an employee has alleged “sexual harassment, “discrimination,” or “retaliation,” for example, it is not the investigator’s job to reach those legal conclusions. The investigator must limit herself or himself to uncovering whether it is “more likely than not” that the facts support the allegations. For example, an investigator can opine that an employee was disciplined because of work performance and not because of any complaint he or she raised. The investigator should not take the further step of concluding the company “did not retaliate” against the employee.
Why? First, an employer might decide not to take remedial action because the investigator did not substantiate the claims of illegal behavior. Because the goal of a workplace investigation, both from a legal and business perspective, should be to resolve behavioral issues before they become unlawful, investigators should focus on the conduct and not the conclusion. Second, investigations typically lack many of the elements present in more drawn-out litigation which might make a legal conclusion premature. Third, making a legal conclusion that the employer does not act upon will definitely be looked upon unfavorably by a jury or agency in subsequent litigation. Finally, a jury is more likely to find against the employer if an investigation report concludes or indicates that the accused’s behavior was unlawful.
Producing a Substandard Report: Should litigation ensue, the investigator’s report will be used to support the company’s legal position, defense, or any determinations made. Investigators must think ahead and assume any privileges will be waived, the report will be disclosed, and discovery will be conducted into the investigation (including a deposition of the investigator). This is particularly true when disciplinary action taken against the subject is severe. If an employee is going to be discharged for wrongful behavior or for violating a company policy, providing a report that outlines the details of the investigation and the reasons for the findings is critical. Reports must have sufficient detail to describe the conflict, the basis for credibility determinations, and the reason for any conclusions reached.
A full, detailed report should summarize the relevant facts based on the information obtained from interviews and documents (or other investigatory work) and should include a detailed analysis and conclusion section. Investigators must avoid unnecessary details that dilute the investigation conclusion, while having the judgment to include relevant findings that might be needed to support the conclusion in litigation months or years later. The report should be a stand-alone road map to the investigator’s conclusion. Meandering reports that lack organization, do not address all aspects of the complaint, or miss an issue that needs to be analyzed, create holes that give ammunition to anyone challenging the investigator’s conclusion.
An often-overlooked misstep is the careless use of language. For example, instead of saying Employee One called Employee Two an “unreasonable” number of times, state the number of times, even if a range. If an employee describes “aggressive” behavior, drill down into what that means in terms of tone, body, language, etc. That way, you let the reader conclude the number was “unreasonable” or an employee’s behavior was “aggressive” without implying a biased investigator.
Failing to Compassionately Deliver the Results of the Investigation: Finally, one of the biggest mistakes I see is the employer’s failure to compassionately deliver the investigation results. The investigator and client should be aligned on how to deliver the results to the accuser and accused. The accuser should walk away feeling that the neutral investigator heard his or her concerns and did what was necessary to investigate them, even if the concerns were not substantiated. Although you should be careful with how much information you reveal given the privacy and confidentiality concerns, the involved parties should be provided with enough information to let them know the investigation is complete, the conclusion, and a general description of what will happen next. More importantly, when delivering the information, be clear, precise, and sensitive to the fact that someone will be disappointed in your factual findings. Litigation is usually the result of an employee not feeling heard or treated fairly. As investigators, we are in a unique position to help avoid this situation.
With increasing scrutiny on appropriate workplace practices and a greater emphasis on corporate accountability, employers must not only ensure their investigation processes are compliant with legal standards but also uphold integrity and inspire trust within their organizations. Properly addressing complaints and conducting meticulous investigations can help prevent potential legal issues, foster a positive work environment, and can mean the difference between a smoothly resolved conflict and a costly, drawn-out lawsuit.