by Andreas Mosby, Associate
Womble Bond Dickinson (US) LLP
In April 2024, the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) issued a regulation banning most non-compete agreements for employees and independent contractors. However, just two weeks before the rule was set to take effect on September 4, 2024, a federal court in Texas blocked its implementation. The FTC may appeal this decision to the Fifth Circuit, a process that could take over a year. It is unlikely that an appeal will succeed, given the current conservative-leaning judiciary, meaning the FTC’s rule will not take effect for the foreseeable future. While employers can still enter into non-compete agreements under state law, the trend toward limiting or voiding non-compete agreements continues to grow nationally.
As we head into the fourth quarter of the year, here is a fall to-do-list for employers to consider regarding non-compete agreements:
Be mindful of federal antitrust laws. Even though the FTC cannot impose a direct nationwide ban on non-compete agreements, it can still target them on a case-by-case basis. The FTC retains the power to bring individual enforcement actions and claim that certain non-compete agreements are unfair methods of competition. It is likely that the FTC will focus on particularly egregious non-compete agreements or those affecting large numbers of employees. The FTC remains empowered under Section 5 of the FTC Act to investigate and bring enforcement actions against unfair competition practices, including non-compete agreements.
Be familiar with state law requirements. State laws on non-compete agreements are continually evolving. Employers should review these agreements to ensure they remain enforceable. Keep in mind the basics: consideration, time period, and geographic scope. Some states demand more than just initial or continued at-will employment for a non-compete agreement to be valid. All non-compete agreements must have reasonable time limits after employment ends, with some states imposing specific caps. Depending on the jurisdiction, employers might also need to specify the exact counties where the non-compete restrictions apply.
Determine whether minimum compensation thresholds apply. Employers need to verify that the individual asked to sign a non-compete agreement meets the minimum compensation threshold required by their jurisdiction, if applicable. For example, a recent Connecticut house bill invalidates non-compete agreements for employees and independent contractors who earn less than three times (for non-exempt hourly or exempt salaried) or five times (for independent contractors) the minimum wage. These amounts may rise annually based on inflation.
Provide advance notice when required. In some states, employers cannot present non-compete agreements to new hires on their first day of employment or to current employees without prior notice. For example, in Colorado, new employees must receive notice before accepting an offer, and current employees must be given 14 days’ notice before the agreement’s effective date.
Assess whether industry specific rules may impact your ability to enforce non-compete agreements. Employers should determine whether their non-compete agreements are affected by industry-specific restrictions or prohibitions. For example, several states have unique statutes, regulations, or court doctrines that specifically restrict non-compete agreements for doctors, nurses, and other healthcare practitioners.
Update restrictive covenant templates. Employers should use this time to reassess the company’s current and future business objectives. Identify non-compete agreement templates and consult with legal counsel to revise them to fit the company’s needs and comply with current and prospective changes to state and federal laws governing non-compete agreements.
Review existing non-solicitation and confidentiality clauses/agreements. Employers can protect sensitive information and client relationships through confidentiality and specific non-solicitation agreements. Well-crafted agreements offer substantial safeguards. Employers should review existing restrictive covenants to ensure they provide adequate protection for information, relationships, and goodwill. If these protections are lacking, now is the time to implement them. Additionally, employers must ensure these covenants do not unintentionally function as non-compete agreements, which could render them unenforceable.
Continue to monitor state legislation. Momentum for state-level non-compete reform has increased in recent years. In 2024, several bills have been introduced or progressed in state legislatures that would restrict or entirely ban non-compete agreements if enacted. Employers will want to closely monitor these developments as we prepare for the upcoming presidential election.
Notify employees of their right to counsel. Employers should be mindful that some states require employers to inform employees in writing that they have the right to consult an attorney before signing a non-compete agreement.
About the Author
Associate
Womble Bond Dickinson (US) LLP
Andreas advises and represents employers across a wide range of industries with respect to various employment law matters, including those involving discrimination, harassment and wrongful termination, labor relations, litigation, pay equity, and wage and hour violations. Andreas’ practice also focuses on advising/counseling employers regarding daily workplace issues and employee handbooks and policies.
Hey NELC Members!
Are you interested in writing substantive law articles like this and getting published in the NELC Quarterly Newsletter? Click here to submit your content/topic ideas.
© 2024 National Employment Law Council (NELC)