by Daveante Jones, Associate
Wright Lindsey Jennings
About three in four Americans identify with a specific religious faith according to an average of all 2021 Gallup polling. With social, political, and legal matters related to religious beliefs impacting hiring practices, workplace culture, employee availability, and compensation/benefits taking center stage in 2023, employers should prioritize making sure their policies and procedures regarding religious protections keep pace.
Legal Protections for Religion in the Workplace
Many state and federal laws impact religious protections in the workplace. Among others, the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution protects the right of religious freedom of religion from government interference. Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits religious discrimination, religious harassment, and retaliation against an individual for their religious beliefs (or lack thereof) and provides a right to religious accommodation absent an undue hardship to employers. The federal government and a number of states also have some form of Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) limiting governments’ ability to burden religious exercise.
Recent Shifts Across the Landscape
Rooted in religious beliefs for many, reproductive rights have caused major shifts in the landscape of religion in the workplace. In 2014, SCOTUS recognized a for-profit corporation’s claim of religious belief for the first time, striking down the Affordable Care Act’s contraceptive mandate requiring employers to cover costs for certain contraceptives for female employees in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc., 573 U.S. 682 (2014). On that same note, 2022 brought about another landmark SCOTUS decision in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, 142 S. Ct. 2228 (2022). Overturning Roe v. Wade, the Court held the U.S. Constitution does not confer a right to abortion and the responsibility in regulating the right to abortion should be left to the states. This has led to significant restrictions on the right to abortion in many states, including some complete prohibitions absent extraordinary circumstances. Employers are now trying to figure out how to handle abortion-related rights and obligations in the workplace while weighing their employees’ social and religious views on the subject. One approach has been offering coverage of travel costs related to abortion-related care for employees working in states with significant restrictions. That, however, has elicited blowback from states accusing employers of facilitating illegal activity and brought about the potential for discrimination against those employees whose religious beliefs place them on the other side of the dichotomy by not giving them a comparable option.
The expansion of workplace protections related to sexual orientation and gender identity has caused a major shift in the landscape of religion in the workplace as well. On June 15, 2020, in Boston v. Clayton County, 590 U.S. __, 140 S. Ct. 1731 (2020), SCOTUS held that prohibition against sex discrimination in Title VII includes discrimination against individuals on the basis of sexual orientation or transgender status. Looking to shed light on the decision and establish its position on LGBTQ+ rights, the EEOC issued guidance entitled Protections Against Employment Discrimination Based on Sexual Orientation or Gender Identity on June 15, 2021. The guidance, among other things, prohibits employers from requiring transgender employees to dress in accordance with the employee’s sex assigned at birth and denying employees equal access to bathrooms, locker rooms, or showers that correspond with employees’ gender identity. The guidance also deems that the use of pronouns or names that are inconsistent with employees’ gender identity could be considered harassment. Notwithstanding its current non-binding status and multiple legal challenges that the issuance does not comply with applicable legal requirements making their way through courts in multiple states, potential friction remains between the rights of LGBTQ+ individuals and employees with conflicting religious beliefs.
A perfect example of this arose in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Arkansas in September 2020. Specifically, the EEOC brought a lawsuit on behalf of employees alleging their employer refused to accommodate their religious belief that homosexuality is a sin and forced them to follow a workplace dress code requiring employees to wear aprons with a rainbow heart and disciplined and terminated them because of their beliefs and in retaliation for requesting an accommodation. See EEOC v. Kroger Limited Partnership, Case No. 4:20-cv-1099-LPR. The parties eventually entered into a consent decree to resolve the case and the employer agreed to create and implement a religious accommodation policy and provide religious discrimination training.
Not to be lost in this, however, are the unfortunate mainstream attacks on religion that highlight the heightened potential for religious harassment in the workplace these days. While a lot of these attacks have centered around anti-Muslim bias in years past, antisemitic attacks have reached an all-time high in the past few years according to the Anti-Defamation League. Additionally, a ResumeBuilder.com November 2022 survey of hiring managers in the U.S. revealed increased hiring and workplace biases related to Jewish applicants and employees.
Changes on the Horizon
As the country tries to navigate through these times, changes are expected. Some of those changes will come through legislatures and administrative agencies. For instance, states like Connecticut, California, New York, and Washington have enacted or are considering workplace freedom of speech legislation restricting how employers may lawfully convey messages to employees about religious and political matters and states like Arkansas, Georgia, New York, and South Carolina have enacted or are considering legislation aimed at including explicit protection for those of the Jewish faith and/or ethnicity. There is the Office of Federal Contract Compliance Programs’ (OFCCP) recent rescission of the Trump-era rule, Implementing Legal Requirements Regarding the Equal Opportunity Clause’s Religious Exemption, aiming to protect workers from discrimination and safeguard principles of religious freedom and eliminate confusion and uncertainty about the religious exemption permitting federal contractors that are qualifying religious organizations to hire individuals of a particular religion. This resulted from the Trump-era rule’s divergence from the Title VII religious exemption approach taken by courts, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, and the Department of Justice, and the OFCCP’s past practice.
The biggest change may be coming from SCOTUS. The Court is expected to address the current standard for what constitutes an undue burden for employers analyzing whether to accommodate employees’ religious practices. Groff v. DeJoy was brought by a former mail carrier who was disciplined for refusing to work on Sundays due to his religious beliefs. Employers have normally not been required to accommodate employees’ religious beliefs if such accommodation would create more than a de minimis burden on the business. Many high-profile Republicans and religious organizations are calling for a more rigorous standard. And most expect a change to come based on the Court’s conservative supermajority and a dissenting opinion issued by Justice Gorsuch in 2021. This could cause a significant ripple effect for employers’ ability to provide sufficient work coverage on weekends and other days involving major religious practices.
Takeaways for Keeping Pace
With so much going on, identifying the major workplace dynamics related to religion and simplifying the approach handling them is crucial. That could include:
All in all, the ultimate goal should be cultivating an inclusive workplace respectful of differing beliefs that attracts, retains, and develops talent while giving everyone a workplace they feel comfortable.
About the Author
Daveante Jones
Associate
Wright Lindsey Jennings
Little Rock, AR
Learning the unique features of his clients to help provide practical and tailored support, Daveante spends his days helping employers navigate day-to-day issues related to hiring, discipline and termination, employee pay, leaves and accommodations, cultivating an inclusive workplace, and conducting employee and management training. Daveante’s support also includes handling all aspects of litigation and internal and state/federal agency investigations, drafting workplace policies and employment agreements, and writing and speaking on the latest legal trends.
Click to learn more about Daveante and his practice.
—-
Daveante will also be leading a roundtable discussion at the NELC Annual Conference on Thursday, May 4 in Washington, D.C. Be sure to register for the event and connect with him in person.
Hey NELC Members!
Are you interested in writing substantive law articles like this and getting published in the NELC Quarterly Newsletter? Click here to submit your content/topic ideas.
© 2023 National Employment Law Council (NELC)